The former lay minister who gave a home to Liverpool bomber Emad al Swealmeen was aware that his Bible meetings were being targeted by Muslims pretending to convert to Christianity.
Malcolm Hitchcott, who was assistant leader of Liverpool Cathedral’s Iranian ministry, told an appeal tribunal: “I am aware that there are some asylum seekers who attend church with the sole purpose of advancing their asylum claims.”
Court records show Mr Hitchcott had refused to baptise one asylum seeker and had identified several who were only pretending to have renounced their faith.
Apostasy is punishable by death in some regimes based on a strict interpretation of Islam, and asylum seekers can use conversion to Christianity as evidence of likely persecution should they be deported.
Deputy upper tribunal judge Gaenor Bruce said Mr Hitchcott “understands that some Iranians might pretend to have found Jesus in order to support a false claim for asylum”.
Judge Bruce summarised Mr Hitchcott’s 2015 evidence in an appeal of an Iranian asylum seeker who had been baptised at Liverpool Cathedral.
“He has personally refused to come to court for other Iranians who attend the cathedral and has also refused to baptise someone,” she wrote.
Liverpool terror attack: Emad al Swealmeen began making ‘relevant purchases’ in April, say terror police
Liverpool terror attack: Suspected bomber exploited UK’s ‘dysfunctional’ asylum system, Priti Patel says
Liverpool terror attack: Tory councillor apologises after sharing image of Jeremy Corbyn superimposed into scene of explosion
She said attempts at bogus conversions were “something that he and other clergy and staff at the cathedral, are very aware of”.
The judge said the number of Iranians attending the cathedral was “improbably large” for them all to be genuine converts.
The court heard that the “Alpha” conversion courses Mr Hitchcott helped to run at the cathedral were so popular with Middle Eastern asylum seekers that clergy found it difficult to cope with the paperwork.
The Very Reverend Dr Pete Wilcox is recorded as telling an appeal hearing in 2015: “For the vast majority of asylum seekers the cathedral will not be able to attend their tribunal hearings, due to the demands of running the very busy cathedral.”
The court was told one asylum seeker, whose appeal was allowed on the grounds he was now a Christian, had referred another five Iranians to the cathedral’s conversion course.
Mr Hitchcott, a former army officer, told the court he could tell when a Muslim asylum seeker had genuinely renounced their faith.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
Judge Bruce allowed at least two appeals, saying she was convinced that clergy at the cathedral had correctly assessed that the conversion of asylum seekers to Christianity was a genuine change of faith.
Mr Hitchcott and the Bishop of Liverpool, Paul Bayes, declined to speak to Sky News.
In a written statement, the diocese of Liverpool said: “Liverpool Cathedral has developed robust processes for discerning whether someone might be expressing a genuine commitment to faith.
“These include requirements for regular attendance alongside taking part in a recognised Christian basics course.
“We would expect someone to be closely connected with the community for at least two years before we would consider supporting an application.”